Is The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West worth it? Honest pros and cons

Yes — The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is worth it for travelers who want a waterfront, marina-front stay on Stock Island with easy access to Old Town, on-site dining, and marina-focused activities. It’s especially good for boaters, couples, and families who value pools, dockside restaurants, and a complimentary shuttle to downtown; it may be less attractive if you want to be in Old Town walking distance or expect a full-service on-site spa.
In this guide
Location: Stock Island waterfront, not Old Town
The Perry sits on Stock Island at 7001 Shrimp Road, minutes from downtown Key West but not in Old Town itself. Expect about a 5-mile transfer to Duval Street — the hotel runs a complimentary hourly shuttle to downtown.
If your priority is being within walking distance of Duval Street nightlife and galleries, this isn’t the spot; if you want a quieter marina setting with easy boat access, it’s a strong match.
- Complimentary hourly shuttle to Old Town (pickup at 201 Williams Street on the half hour; shuttle hours listed 9:00 AM–11:00 PM).
- Nearest airport: Key West International Airport (EYW), roughly a 3-mile drive.
- Good base for marina activities, but plan transport if you want frequent downtown trips.
| From The Perry | Typical time/distance |
|---|---|
| Duval Street / Old Town | About 5 miles (shuttle available) |
| Key West International Airport (EYW) | About 3 miles |
| Key West Tropical Forest & Botanical Garden | About 1 mile |

Rooms and suites: choices for couples, families, and boaters
The Perry has 100 rooms and suites across three floors with a mix of standard rooms, studios, and larger suites. Room categories include The Commodore Suite, Grand Suite, Room (Stock Island), Room (Mangrove), Room (Perry), Studio, with Sofa bed (Salt Water), Studio, Poolside (Lanai), and Studio Suite, Poolside (Lanai).
Room layouts and bedding vary by type (King Bed and/or 2 Queen Beds in many options); select suites and studios include sofa beds for extra guests. ADA-compliant rooms are available.
- The Commodore Suite — 1 King Bed and 1 Double Sofa Bed.
- Grand Suite — 1 King Bed and 1 Double Sofa Bed.
- Room (Stock Island), Room (Mangrove), Room (Perry) — options with 1 King Bed or 2 Queen Beds.
- Studio options include Salt Water (king + sofa bed), Poolside (Lanai) studios, and Studio Suite, Poolside (Lanai) with 1 King Bed.
| Room type | Typical bedding |
|---|---|
| The Commodore Suite | 1 King Bed + 1 Double Sofa Bed |
| Grand Suite | 1 King Bed + 1 Double Sofa Bed |
| Room (Stock Island) / Room (Mangrove) / Room (Perry) | 1 King Bed or 2 Queen Beds |

Pools, marina and on-site activities
The property offers two outdoor waterfront pools (one listed as heated) with sun loungers and two poolside bars; towels are provided under the mandatory resort fee. The marina is a major draw: a 288-slip deep-water marina with an 18-foot draft that can accommodate very large vessels.
On-site activities and services include bicycle rentals, concierge-arranged boating and scuba activities, and partner-arranged massage services (in-room, balcony, or poolside). Dogs are not allowed on the pool deck or in pools.
- Two outdoor waterfront pools (pool hours vary by source; check current hours at check-in).
- 288-slip marina with fuel, shore power, and slips up to 300 feet vessel length capacity.
- Bicycle rentals on site; water activities and boat charters bookable via marina/concierge.
- No dogs on pool deck or in pools; two on-site dog exercise areas elsewhere on property.
| Facility | Notes |
|---|---|
| Pools | Two waterfront pools; one reported as heated |
| Marina | 288 deep-water slips; 18-foot draft |
| Wellness | 24-hour fitness center; partner massage services available |
Dining: dockside seafood and casual grill options
Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar is the hotel’s main waterfront restaurant serving seafood and Southern-influenced American coastal dishes with set hours for breakfast/brunch and dinner; reservations are available. Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill is an open-air poolside/dockside option for burgers, sandwiches, tacos and daily happy hour.
There have been additional food outlets tied to the property in the past; check current on-site restaurant availability and hours before arrival.
- Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar — Breakfast and brunch hours plus dinner nightly; reservations available online.
- Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill — Casual dockside/poolside menu; no reservations required.
- Two poolside bars for drinks and light bites by the pools and marina.
| Restaurant / Bar | Typical service |
|---|---|
| Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar | Breakfast, Brunch (weekend), Dinner; reservations recommended for dinner |
| Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill | Casual dockside/poolside; walk-in; happy hour daily |
| Poolside bars (2) | Drinks and light bites |

Pricing, fees and useful policies
The Perry charges a mandatory daily resort fee; the property’s site has listed a specific fee amount, but third-party sites have shown different amounts over time. The resort fee covers shuttle access, a champagne welcome, coffee/tea stations, pool towels, and 24-hour fitness center use.
Check-in begins at 4:00 PM (guests may arrive anytime up until midnight) and check-out is at 11:00 AM. The minimum check-in age is 21 (guests under 21 generally must be accompanied by a parent or guardian).
- Mandatory resort fee (amount quoted on the property site; amounts vary on third-party sites).
- Check-in: 4:00 PM; guests may arrive up until midnight. Check-out: 11:00 AM.
- Photo ID and credit card required at check-in; hotel accepts major credit cards.
- Pet policy: dogs allowed (up to 2 dogs per room) with pet fee ($75/night first dog, $25/night second dog).
| Policy | What to expect |
|---|---|
| Resort fee | Mandatory; covers shuttle, towels, fitness access and other amenities |
| Pet fee | $75/night for first dog, $25/night for second dog (dogs only) |
| Minimum check-in age | 21 years |
Who should stay here — pros and cons
Pros: The Perry is a good choice if you want marina access, waterfront pools, dockside dining, a 24-hour gym, and easy booking of boat-based activities. The complimentary shuttle to Old Town makes downtown visits convenient without staying in the busy heart of Key West.
Cons: If you want to be within walking distance of Duval Street nightlife and galleries or need an on-site, branded full-service spa, you may prefer a downtown hotel. Also, mandatory resort fees and parking fees (reported separately on third-party sites) add to the nightly cost.
- Good for: boaters, couples, families who don’t need Old Town walking access, guests who value pools and dockside restaurants.
- Less good for: travelers who want to walk to Duval Street, those seeking a full-service on-site spa, or budget travelers sensitive to resort/parking fees.
| Strengths | Limitations |
|---|---|
| Large deep-water marina, watersports access, two waterfront pools | Not within walking distance of Old Town; shuttle needed |
| On-site dockside dining and two pool bars | Resort fee and potential parking fees increase total cost |
| Dog-friendly with on-site dog areas | Dogs not allowed on pool deck or in pools |
Practical tips before you book
Confirm the current resort fee and any parking charges with reservations, since third-party sites list different amounts. If you plan to use the pool or spa services, check pool hours and whether massages require advance booking through the concierge.
Ask about shuttle schedules for the dates you travel and whether pick-up times downtown match your plans; also confirm restaurant hours and whether you should reserve Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar for dinner.
- Verify resort fee amount and what it covers at the time of booking.
- Reserve boat excursions or scuba dives in advance via the marina/concierge if you have specific dates in mind.
- If traveling with a dog, confirm the pet fee and bring any needed documentation; dogs are not allowed on pool deck.
| Before arrival | Ask/confirm |
|---|---|
| Fees | Current resort fee amount and parking charges |
| Transport | Shuttle hours and pickup locations |
| Dining & activities | Restaurant hours and event/boat bookings |


