
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Best for marina access, boaters, and travelers who want dockside dining and a waterfront pool setting.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a 100-room waterfront hotel on Stock Island with a large deep-water marina and two outdoor waterfront pools—good for travelers who want marina access, dockside dining, and an easy shuttle to Old Town. Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection is a historic, oceanfront 4-star resort on Key West’s largest private beach—best for travelers who want a classic beachfront resort experience near Old Town.
Updated · about 5 miles (≈8 km) apart

Best for marina access, boaters, and travelers who want dockside dining and a waterfront pool setting.

Best for classic oceanfront resort stays with a private beach and full-service spa options.
When The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West wins: choose The Perry if you want a working marina (288 deep-water slips), a compact boutique scale (100 rooms), dockside restaurants and quick marina-based water activities, or if you value the complimentary shuttle to Old Town and on-site bike/scooter rentals.
When Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection wins: pick Casa Marina if a private stretch of beach, a larger traditional resort footprint (311 rooms), on-site full-service spa, and historic oceanfront setting matter most to your Key West stay.
Bottom line: The Perry is the better pick for boating, a smaller waterfront-hotel feel, and easy marina access; Casa Marina is the better pick for a beachfront resort experience and a hotel with a branded full-service spa and more room types.
| Category | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West | Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique waterfront marina hotel with contemporary dockside dining. | Historic oceanfront luxury resort on a private beach with a traditional resort layout. |
| Location (to Old Town / Duval) | Located on Stock Island; about 5 miles from Duval Street with a complimentary hourly shuttle. | In Old Town Key West (steps from Florida Keys Beaches and about 0.6 mi/0.9 km from South Beach). |
| Size (rooms) | 100 rooms and suites. | 311 rooms (Curio Collection listing). |
| Who it's for | Boat owners, couples and families who want marina life and a quieter waterfront base. | Beach-focused guests, travelers wanting a historic flagship resort and a full-service spa. |
| Pools & beach | Two outdoor waterfront pools (one heated); no private beach but marina and dock access. | Two outdoor pools plus a private beach (on-site). |
| Restaurants & bars | Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar, Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill, plus two poolside bars and dockside options. | Morrison’s Market café, a bar/lounge and a beach bar; room service (limited hours). |
| Wellness & spa | No branded in-house spa; partner massage services and lawn yoga classes; 24-hour fitness center (included in resort fee). | Full-service spa offering massages, body treatments and facials (on-site). |
| Known for | The 288-slip deep-water marina and dockside dining. | Historic resort on Key West’s largest private beach and Hilton Curio branding. |
| Event & meeting space | Multiple indoor/outdoor venues and over 20,000 sq ft of event space across six venues, several waterfront options. | Conference space totaling about 10,504 sq ft with 7 meeting rooms. |
| Distance between properties | about 5 miles (≈8 km) apart | |
The Perry sits on Stock Island at a working marina—minutes from downtown Key West by car or the hotel shuttle.
Choose The Perry if you want marina access and don’t need to be in Old Town proper.
Casa Marina sits in Old Town on a historic oceanfront parcel with its own private beach.
Pick Casa Marina if you want Old Town access and beachfront walking proximity to Duval and local sites.
The Perry has 100 rooms and suites with a compact set of room types focused on waterfront or poolside locations.
The Perry is smaller and simpler—good if you want a waterfront room and a boutique scale.
Casa Marina offers a wide range of room categories across 311 rooms with many ocean-, pool- and beach-facing options.
Casa Marina gives more room types and dedicated oceanfront suites for guests prioritizing beach views and variety.
The Perry’s dining centers on waterfront seafood and casual dockside options.
The Perry emphasizes local seafood and dockside casual dining tied to the marina experience.
Casa Marina mixes a main restaurant/café with beach bar and lounge options under Hilton Curio service standards.
Casa Marina is set up for beachside resort dining and casual-to-upscale resort meals.
The Perry provides two outdoor waterfront pools and direct marina/dock access for water activities.
If marina views and poolside dockside bars are your priority, The Perry fits well.
Casa Marina’s signature amenity is its private stretch of beach plus two outdoor pools.
Choose Casa Marina if a private beach and classic resort pool/beach setup are central to your trip.
The Perry focuses on fitness and outdoor wellness rather than a branded in-house spa.
The Perry covers basic fitness needs and can arrange massages, but it does not operate a branded full-service spa.
Casa Marina operates a full-service spa and typical resort wellness offerings.
Casa Marina is the stronger pick for an on-site spa and traditional resort wellness services.

The Perry — on-site 288-slip deep-water marina with dockside services and direct ocean access.

Casa Marina — historic property with Key West’s largest private beach and full beachfront service.

The Perry — 100 rooms, compact layout, and intimate dockside dining options.

Casa Marina — 311 rooms, an on-site full-service spa, and more room-type variety.
Casa Marina is in Old Town and within walking distance of Duval Street; The Perry is on Stock Island about 5 miles away and offers a complimentary shuttle to Old Town.
The Perry is the clear choice: it has a 288-slip deep-water marina and on-site marina services.
Casa Marina has Key West’s largest private beach; The Perry does not have a private beach but provides marina and dock access.
Casa Marina lists a full-service on-site spa. The Perry arranges partner massage services and lawn yoga but does not operate a branded in-house spa.
Explore how The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·