
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Best for guests who want a working marina, on-site boating services, and easy access to marina-based excursions.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a 100-room waterfront boutique on Stock Island with a large deep-water marina and two outdoor pools—good for travelers who want marina life, boat access, and a short shuttle ride to Old Town. The Reach Key West, Curio Collection is an upscale, Hilton-affiliated beachfront resort in Old Town with a private beach feel—best for travelers who want beach access and easy walking distance to Duval Street.
Updated · about 5 miles apart

Best for guests who want a working marina, on-site boating services, and easy access to marina-based excursions.

Best for travelers who prioritize a true beachfront location and walking access to Old Town Key West attractions.
When The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West wins: choose The Perry if you plan to use the marina (sailing, diving, private charters), want larger event/wedding spaces, or are bringing a dog—its marina facilities and on-site boat access are distinctive.
When The Reach Key West, Curio Collection wins: choose The Reach if you want to be in Old Town within walking distance of Duval Street and Southernmost Point, prefer private sandy beach access, and want an upscale Curio/Hilton-branded resort experience.
Bottom line: pick The Perry for marina-focused stays, water-sport logistics, and poolside dock dining on Stock Island; pick The Reach for beachfront proximity to Old Town and a classic Hilton upscale beach resort feel.
| Category | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West | The Reach Key West, Curio Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique waterfront marina hotel, casual to casual-elegant dining | Upscale beachfront Curio Collection resort with a private beach feel |
| Location | Stock Island waterfront, about a 20-minute drive to Old Town | Old Town Key West on Simonton Street, steps from Duval and Southernmost Point |
| Size | 100 rooms and suites | 150 individually decorated guestrooms (supplier listing) |
| Ages / check-in | All ages welcome; 21+ to check in | All ages welcome; supplier listing indicates standard resort policies (check-in min age not published) |
| Pools & beach | Two outdoor waterfront pools (one heated) and poolside bars; no private beach | One outdoor pool and a private beach on-site |
| Restaurants & bars | Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar, Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill, two poolside bars; dockside dining | Four Marlins restaurant plus poolside bar; room service and poolside bar options |
| Spa & wellness | On-site 24-hour fitness center; partnered in-room and on-site massage services (no named full spa) | Full-service spa with massages and treatment rooms (supplier listing) |
| Unique strengths | 288-slip deep-water marina, extensive event/wedding venues, complimentary shuttle to Old Town | Private beach, close walk to Duval Street and Old Town attractions |
| Pet policy | Dog-friendly (fee: $75/night first dog, $25/night second dog); dogs not allowed on pool deck | Not published |
| Brand / affiliation | Independent / boutique (BookResorts listing and hotel site) | Curio Collection by Hilton (Hilton-affiliated) |
The Perry sits on Stock Island at a working deep-water marina about 5 miles from downtown Key West.
Best if you want marina access and don’t mind a short drive or shuttle ride into Old Town.
The Reach is in Old Town Key West on Simonton Street with direct access to a private beach and short walks to Duval Street attractions.
Best if you want to stay in Old Town with direct beach access and walkable nightlife and sights.
The Perry’s 100 rooms and suites are arranged across three floors with waterside and garden-facing options.
Rooms skew toward practical, marina-facing lodging with a few larger suites for families or groups.
The Reach offers a mix of studio and suite room types with many labeled Ocean View or Resort View.
Rooms are focused on ocean and resort views, with more beachfront-oriented room categories and private balconies common.
The Perry emphasizes dockside dining and casual-elegant seafood with two main restaurants and pool bars.
Good choice if you want waterfront dining tied to marina and dockside character.
The Reach features on-site restaurant Four Marlins plus a poolside bar and limited room service hours.
Better if you prefer classic resort dining steps from the beach and quick access to Old Town restaurants.
The Perry highlights two outdoor waterfront pools (one heated) with marina views and poolside bars.
Pick The Perry if poolside marina views and on-water activities are more important than sand access.
The Reach offers an outdoor pool plus on-site private beach—its primary draw for many guests.
Choose The Reach for direct beachfront time and a resort-style beach/pool layout in Old Town.
The Perry keeps wellness straightforward—24-hour fitness, yoga classes, and partner massage services.
Good for active travelers who want fitness and occasional on-site wellness without a full spa complex.
The Reach provides a full-service spa and easy nighttime access to Old Town bars and restaurants by foot.
Better if you want resort-spa services plus immediate access to Old Town nightlife.

The Perry — on-site 288-slip deep-water marina and direct access to charters and dive operators.

The Reach — private beach and a short walk to Duval Street and Southernmost Point.

The Perry — extensive event spaces and multiple outdoor waterfront venues for large ceremonies.

The Reach — Curio Collection by Hilton branding, full-service spa, and Old Town location.
The Reach is in Old Town within easy walking distance to Duval Street; The Perry is on Stock Island about a 20-minute drive or a shuttle ride away.
The Perry — it has a 288-slip deep-water marina and on-site access to charter boats and diving operators.
The Reach has on-site private beach access; The Perry does not have a private sand beach.
No—both hotels welcome guests of all ages, though The Perry requires the primary guest to be at least 21 to check in.
Explore how The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·