
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Best for boating, anglers, and guests who need direct marina access and dockside dining.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a 100-room waterfront hotel on Stock Island built around a 288-slip deep-water marina, best for travelers who plan to boat or want a quieter marina-side stay with easy shuttle access to Old Town. Pier House Resort & Spa is a classic Old Town waterfront resort at Mallory Square with a full-service spa and a private beach area — read this if you want downtown convenience, sunset views, and on-site spa services.
Updated · about 5 miles (8 km) apart

Best for boating, anglers, and guests who need direct marina access and dockside dining.

Best for staying steps from Mallory Square, downtown restaurants/bars, and a traditional Old Town beach/resort experience.
When The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West wins: choose The Perry if your trip centers on boating, private vessel access, or a relaxed marina setting with dockside restaurants and two waterfront pools. It’s the easy choice for guests who want a quieter base and direct marina services.
When Pier House Resort & Spa wins: choose Pier House if you want to be in Old Town near Duval Street and Mallory Square, prefer a property with a named full-service spa and a small private beachfront area, and want immediate access to downtown nightlife and museums.
Bottom line: The Perry is the marina-first option on Stock Island (best for boaters and those seeking a quieter waterfront stay), while Pier House is the downtown waterfront pick for guests prioritizing Old Town location, a dedicated spa, and proximity to Mallory Square.
| Category | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West | Pier House Resort & Spa |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Marina-focused, quieter Stock Island property with a boating/active-water-sports emphasis. | Classic Old Town waterfront resort with seaside/beach access and downtown energy. |
| Location | Stock Island, minutes from downtown via complimentary hourly shuttle; about 5 miles from Duval Street. | Mallory Square/Old Town, steps from Duval Street and downtown attractions. |
| Size / rooms | 100 rooms and suites across 3 floors. | 142 individually decorated guestrooms. |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21. | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age not published. |
| Pools | Two outdoor waterfront pools (one heated), poolside bars and sun loungers. | One outdoor pool and poolside bar; beach umbrellas and sun loungers on private beach area. |
| Restaurants & bars | Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar, Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill, two poolside bars, dockside dining options. | One main restaurant, 2 bars/lounges, a beach bar and poolside bar; room service available (limited hours). |
| Spa & wellness | Partner-arranged in-room or poolside massages and Saturday lawn yoga; no branded on-site full-service spa. | Full-service spa offering massages, body treatments and facials; health club on site. |
| Known for | A large 288-slip deep-water marina and marina-centered dining and events. | Prime Old Town harborfront location steps from Mallory Square and downtown nightlife. |
| Event & meeting space | Extensive event venues including Event Lawn, Marina Village Pool, multiple indoor meeting rooms (20,000+ sq ft of event space across venues). | Conference space of 2,605 sq ft and 2 meeting rooms; wedding services available. |
| Shuttle / access to Old Town | Complimentary hourly shuttle to Old Town (about 9am–11pm). | Steps to Old Town — no shuttle required. |
The Perry sits on Stock Island’s working marina, a short drive (or the hotel shuttle) from Old Town.
Choose The Perry if marina access, boat logistics, or a quieter waterfront base is important.
Pier House is in Old Town at Mallory Square, an immediate harborfront location for downtown sightseeing and nightly sunset viewing.
Choose Pier House for maximum Old Town convenience and immediate sunset-harbor access.
The Perry offers 8 room types with waterside and poolside studio options and a few suites.
Expect modern, waterfront-leaning room options with family- and dog-friendly policies.
Pier House lists a wide mix of room types and suites, many individually decorated and some oceanfront/lanai options.
Pier House offers more room variety and named suite types, including explicit oceanfront and spa-suite options.
The Perry emphasizes dockside restaurants and casual, marina-side dining.
Pick The Perry for dock-to-table seafood, casual outdoor dining, and a marina-side meal scene.
Pier House provides on-site restaurant service and two bars/lounges with downtown access for many more options nearby.
Pier House is convenient for guests who want hotel dining plus immediate access to Old Town’s bars and restaurants.
The Perry has two outdoor waterfront pools overlooking the marina, including one heated pool.
Good pool setup for relaxing by the marina; not a beach resort.
Pier House features an outdoor pool and a small private beach area with beach amenities.
Choose Pier House if you want a downtown property with a beach-feel plus a pool.
The Perry offers partner-arranged massage services and a 24-hour fitness center, but no dedicated on-site branded spa.
The Perry covers fitness and basic wellness needs but is not a spa resort.
Pier House includes a full-service spa, a health club, and direct access to Old Town nightlife.
Pier House is the stronger choice for on-site spa services and immediate downtown nightlife access.

The Perry — direct access to a 288-slip deep-water marina and full marina services.

Pier House — steps from Mallory Square and Duval Street for sightseeing and nightlife.

Pier House — a named full-service spa with treatments and a health club.

The Perry — multiple dockside restaurants, two poolside bars, and waterfront menus.
Pier House is in Old Town at Mallory Square and is steps from Duval Street; The Perry is on Stock Island about 5 miles away with a complimentary shuttle.
Pier House Resort & Spa operates a full-service spa; The Perry arranges partner massage services (in-room, balcony or poolside) rather than a branded on-site spa.
The Perry is the clear choice — it has a 288-slip deep-water marina with fuel, shore power and slips that accommodate large vessels.
No — both properties welcome guests of all ages. The Perry requires the primary registrant to be at least 21 to check in; Pier House’s minimum check-in age is not published in the supplied listing.
Explore how The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·