
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Best for boaters, families, and travelers who want a marina, on-site dockside dining, and complimentary shuttle to Old Town.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a 100-room, family-friendly waterfront hotel on Stock Island with a 288-slip marina and two outdoor pools—good for boaters, families, and guests who want easy marina access. The Saint Hotel Key West, Autograph Collection is an adults-only, 36-room boutique Marriott property steps from Duval Street—best for adults who want to stay in Old Town near nightlife and galleries.
Updated · about 5 miles (8 km) apart

Best for boaters, families, and travelers who want a marina, on-site dockside dining, and complimentary shuttle to Old Town.

Best for adults seeking a compact, central Old Town location with boutique Autograph Collection service and a rooftop terrace/pool vibe.
When The Perry wins: choose The Perry if you want marina access (288 deep-water slips), room for families or dogs, two waterfront pools and dockside restaurants—it’s a full-service waterfront property with event space and a complimentary shuttle to Old Town.
When The Saint wins: choose The Saint Hotel Key West, Autograph Collection if you want to be steps from Duval Street and downtown attractions and prefer an adults-only boutique hotel in a smaller, more central Old Town setting.
Bottom line: pick The Perry for marina life, space, and family- or pet-friendly amenities; pick The Saint for a compact, adults-only stay in the heart of Old Town near Duval Street.
| Category | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West | The Saint Hotel Key West, Autograph Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Waterfront marina resort geared to couples, families and boaters | Adults-only boutique hotel focused on an Old Town, nightlife-forward location |
| Location | Stock Island, about 5 miles from Duval Street; on a deep-water marina | 417 Eaton Street, steps from Duval Street and Old Town attractions |
| Size | 100 rooms and suites across three floors | 36 air-conditioned rooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21 | Adults-only property; guests under 18 not permitted |
| Pools | Two outdoor waterfront pools (one heated), poolside bars | One outdoor pool and a rooftop terrace (pool listed in supplier listing) |
| Restaurants & bars | Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar, Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill, two poolside bars (dockside dining emphasized) | Tempt bistro with pool view and a bar/lounge; room service during limited hours |
| Spa / wellness | On-site fitness center (24-hour); partner massage services and lawn yoga; no branded spa | Fitness center listed; Not published |
| Known for | Large deep-water marina (288 slips) and waterfront dining/events | Adults-only Autograph Collection location steps from Duval Street |
| Transport to Old Town | Complimentary hourly shuttle to Old Town (roughly 9am–11pm) | Walking distance to Old Town and Duval Street (steps away) |
| Pet policy | Dog-friendly (fee: $75 first dog/night, $25 second dog/night; two on-site dog exercise areas) | Not published |
The Perry sits on Stock Island at a large deep-water marina, a short drive and complimentary shuttle ride from Old Town Key West.
Choose The Perry if you want on-water access and don’t need to be in Old Town.
The Saint is in Old Town, steps from Duval Street, galleries, and nightlife—ideal for travelers who want to walk everywhere.
Choose The Saint if you want an Old Town location and walking access to bars, restaurants, and galleries.
The Perry has 100 rooms and suites with larger layouts and family-friendly configurations, including suites with sofa beds.
The Perry is better if you need space, extra beds, or a pet-friendly room.
The Saint offers 36 air-conditioned rooms in boutique configurations (king, queen, lofts and studios).
The Saint is right-sized for adults wanting compact, design-forward rooms in Old Town.
The Perry emphasizes dockside seafood and casual waterfront dining with multiple on-site bars.
The Perry is the pick for varied waterfront dining and a relaxed dockside scene.
The Saint has Tempt, a bistro with American cuisine, a bar/lounge and pool views; room service is available on a limited schedule.
The Saint is a good choice if you plan to eat out in Old Town and want a smaller in-house dining program.
The Perry’s signature features are its two outdoor waterfront pools and the large marina.
If pools and marina access are priorities, The Perry offers more pool space and direct on-water access.
The Saint highlights a rooftop terrace and a single outdoor pool as part of its compact, adults-only offering.
The Saint’s pool and rooftop fit a smaller, social Old Town stay rather than a marina-resort environment.
The Perry combines a 24-hour fitness center, occasional yoga and more event space for weddings and meetings.
The Perry is set up for weddings, meetings and fitness access alongside marina recreation.
The Saint puts you in walking distance of Old Town nightlife and offers concierge services for local activities.
The Saint is the better choice if you want immediate nightlife and walkable Old Town access.

The Perry — 288 deep-water marina slips and full marina services for private boats and charters.

The Saint — steps from Duval Street and Old Town attractions, so you can walk to bars, galleries and sights.

The Perry — all ages welcome and dog-friendly with two on-site dog exercise areas and family room types.

The Saint — adults-only Autograph Collection property tailored to adults wanting a compact, central stay.
Choose The Saint for a walkable Old Town location steps from Duval Street; choose The Perry if you don’t mind a short shuttle or drive and prefer marina access.
The Perry — it has a 288-slip deep-water marina and direct on-site access for sailing, motor boating and scuba diving.
The Perry is dog-friendly (fees apply, two on-site dog exercise areas). The Saint’s supplier listing does not publish a pet policy here.
The Saint puts you within steps of Old Town nightlife and restaurants; The Perry offers dockside dining and a shuttle to Old Town if you prefer on-site waterfront meals.
Explore how The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·