
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Best for boaters and marina access — large 288-slip deep-water marina and on-site dock services.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a marina-centered, family-friendly waterfront hotel on Stock Island with two outdoor pools and a large deep-water marina; this guide is for travelers who want easy access to boating, pool time, and a quieter base near Key West. The Marker Key West Harbor Resort is a modern, upscale harborfront resort in Old Town near the Historic Seaport with multiple pools and a walkable location; read on if you prefer being steps from downtown nightlife and harbor attractions.
Updated · about 3.0 mi apart

Best for boaters and marina access — large 288-slip deep-water marina and on-site dock services.

Best for walkable Old Town access — modern harborfront location within steps of the Historic Seaport and Duval Street nightlife.
When The Perry wins: choose The Perry if your trip centers on boating, private-boat access, or you want a quieter waterfront stay on Stock Island with an on-site marina and dockside dining.
When The Marker wins: pick The Marker if you want to be in Old Town walking distance to the historic seaport, restaurants, and bars, or if having multiple pools steps from downtown matters more than marina services.
Bottom line: both are upscale Key West-area options; pick The Perry for marina-focused stays and easy boat access, and The Marker for a modern harborfront base close to Old Town attractions.
| Category | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West | The Marker Key West Harbor Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Marina-focused, relaxed waterfront on Stock Island | Modern harborfront resort near Old Town and the Historic Seaport |
| Location (to Old Town) | On Stock Island, roughly 3 miles / a short drive or shuttle ride to Old Town | In Key West Historic District — within walking distance of Duval Street and the seaport |
| Size (rooms) | 100 rooms and suites | 96 rooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; 21+ to check in | |
| Pools | Two outdoor waterfront pools (one heated) with two pool bars | Three outdoor pools and a poolside restaurant/bar |
| Restaurants & bars | Two dockside restaurants (Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar, Salty Oyster) plus poolside bars and dock grills | One restaurant (Starboard) plus a poolside bar and room service (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | Partner massage services and Saturday lawn yoga; no branded on-site spa | Not published |
| Fitness | 24-hour fitness center (included with resort fee) | |
| Marina / boating | Yes — 288-slip deep-water marina (largest in the Keys) with 18' draft | Marina nearby / harborfront location and boat tours nearby |
| Shuttle & transport | Complimentary hourly shuttle to Old Town (roughly 9am–11pm) | No published shuttle; walkable to downtown attractions |
The Perry sits on Stock Island at a large, working deep-water marina — quieter, with direct boat access.
The Perry is best if you want marina access and a less congested waterfront setting with shuttle service to Old Town.
The Marker sits on the Key West harbor in the Historic District, putting restaurants, bars, and the seaport within easy walking distance.
The Marker is a better pick for travelers who want to stay in the center of Key West activity and walk to the seaport.
The Perry offers 100 rooms and suites across several room types, including dedicated suites and studio options.
Choose The Perry for a wider selection of suite-style rooms and marina-facing accommodations, especially if traveling with a dog.
The Marker has 96 air-conditioned rooms with private balconies or patios and modern harborfront styling.
The Marker suits travelers who want contemporary rooms in a walkable Old Town location; exact room-name breakdown not published in the supplied listing.
The Perry emphasizes dockside dining and casual waterfront restaurants tied to its marina setting.
For on-site seafood and marina-side meals, The Perry’s dockside restaurants and pool bars are the clear draw.
The Marker offers a poolside restaurant (Starboard) and pool bar service, focused on resort-style dining close to Old Town venues.
The Marker’s on-site dining covers basics and poolside meals, with an advantage of many off-property restaurants within steps.
The Perry highlights two outdoor waterfront pools with marina views and poolside bars.
The Perry focuses on marina-side pool time with water views and a relaxed deck atmosphere.
The Marker lists three outdoor pools and poolside amenities as a central part of its resort offer.
If pool variety and resort-style lounging are priorities, The Marker’s three pools make it appealing.
The Perry includes a 24-hour fitness center and outsources massage and wellness services.
The Perry covers fitness and occasional wellness classes but relies on partners for spa treatments; nightlife is a short shuttle or drive away.
The Marker lists fitness facilities and positions guests within walking distance of Old Town nightlife.
The Marker puts you in the middle of Key West after-dark activity; spa details are not published in the provided listing.

The Perry — large 288-slip deep-water marina with full dock services and direct access to open water.

The Marker — right on the harbor and a short walk to Duval Street, Mallory Square, and seaport activities.

The Marker — three outdoor pools give more pool-lounging options close to downtown.

The Perry — multiple dockside restaurants (Matt’s and Salty Oyster) and marina-side dining choices.
The Marker is located in Old Town within walking distance of Duval Street; The Perry is on Stock Island about a 3-mile drive or shuttle ride from Duval.
The Perry is explicitly dog-friendly with on-site dog exercise areas and a published pet fee; The Marker’s supplier listing notes a pet fee but policies should be checked with the hotel directly.
Yes — The Perry has a 288-slip deep-water marina on site. The Marker is harborfront with boat tours and marina access nearby but does not list a comparable private marina size in the supplied listing.
The Perry uses partner massage services (in-room, balcony, or poolside) rather than a branded full-service spa. The Marker’s supplied listing does not publish a dedicated on-site spa name or full spa offerings.
Explore how The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·