
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Best for travelers who want marina access, dockside dining, and a shuttle to Old Town.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a 100-room waterfront hotel on Stock Island with a large deep-water marina and two outdoor pools, aimed at travelers who want marina access and easy Old Town shuttle service. Margaritaville Beach House Key West is a 4-star, beach-oriented resort near Smathers Beach for guests who prefer a casual beach-house vibe and straightforward access to sand and seaside activities.
Updated

Best for travelers who want marina access, dockside dining, and a shuttle to Old Town.

Best for travelers who prioritize a laid-back beach-house stay steps from Smathers Beach and on-site beach-style amenities.
When The Perry wins: Choose The Perry if you want a working marina, dockside restaurants (Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar and Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill), event space, and a strong shuttle connection to Old Town. It's the better pick for boaters and guests who want waterfront marina activities.
When Margaritaville Beach House wins: Pick Margaritaville Beach House Key West if you want a beachside property close to Smathers Beach with a recognizable, casual brand and a single outdoor pool, plus easy airport access.
Bottom line: The Perry suits guests after marina access, multiple waterfront pools, and on-site boating services; Margaritaville Beach House is a simpler beach-oriented option for people who plan to spend time on Smathers Beach and want a laid-back resort feel.
| Category | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West | Margaritaville Beach House Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Marina-focused, slightly upscale casual with dockside dining and boating services | Laid-back beach-house resort near Smathers Beach |
| Location | Stock Island waterfront, minutes from Old Town via complimentary shuttle | On the ocean near Smathers Beach (Key West south side) |
| Size (rooms) | 100 rooms and suites | 186 rooms (supplier listing) |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; 21+ to check in | |
| Pools | Two outdoor waterfront pools (one heated); two poolside bars | One outdoor pool; poolside bar service |
| Restaurants & bars | Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar, Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill, two poolside bars; dockside dining | One on-site restaurant, bar/lounge and poolside bar; room service available (limited hours) |
| Spa / wellness | On-site partner massage services and Saturday lawn yoga (no branded spa) | Health or beauty spa nearby / Not published |
| Known for | 288-slip deep-water marina and waterfront event spaces | Beach access and Margaritaville brand appeal |
| Shuttle / airport | Complimentary hourly shuttle to Old Town; nearest airport Key West Intl. (EYW) | Complimentary roundtrip airport shuttle (available on request); nearest airport Key West Intl. (EYW) |
| Accessibility & family features | Dog-friendly (fees), accessible rooms, family dining, two on-site dog exercise areas | Accessible features listed (wheelchair-accessible rooms/paths), family amenities and kids' games available |
The Perry sits on Stock Island’s waterfront at a working marina, a short drive or the hotel shuttle from Old Town.
Choose The Perry if you want marina access and easy scheduled transport to Old Town.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West sits close to Smathers Beach on the south side of Key West.
Choose Margaritaville Beach House for straightforward beach access and a relaxed beachfront environment.
The Perry has 100 rooms and suites across several room types designed for couples, families and boaters.
The Perry’s smaller inventory and suite options work well for guests who value water views or are traveling with pets.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West lists a broad set of suites and room types across 186 rooms.
Margaritaville Beach House offers more rooms and suite configurations, which can help when booking family or multi-room stays.
Dining at The Perry emphasizes dockside seafood and waterfront settings.
The Perry is best if dockside seafood and multiple waterfront dining options matter to you.
Margaritaville Beach House follows a beach-house dining style with one main restaurant and poolside options.
Margaritaville Beach House suits guests who want simple beachside dining and a single restaurant to rely on.
The Perry features two outdoor waterfront pools overlooking the marina and poolside bar service.
Pick The Perry if pool decks with marina views and multiple pool options are priorities.
Margaritaville Beach House offers an outdoor pool and direct proximity to Smathers Beach.
Margaritaville Beach House is the better fit if you plan to spend most of your time at the beach rather than the pool.
The Perry offers 24-hour fitness and partner-provided massage services plus on-site evening dining and bars.
The Perry provides basic wellness amenities plus easy access to Old Town nightlife via the shuttle.
Margaritaville Beach House lists fitness facilities and nearby spa options, with on-property casual evening venues.
Margaritaville Beach House is a relaxed spot for low-key evenings and beachside downtime; full-service spa details are not published.

The Perry — on-site 288-slip deep-water marina with fueling and services for large vessels.

Margaritaville Beach House — near Smathers Beach with an on-site beach-house atmosphere.

The Perry — multiple dockside venues including Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar and the Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill.

Margaritaville Beach House — 186 rooms and many suite configurations for families or groups.
The Perry is on Stock Island and offers a complimentary hourly shuttle to Old Town; Margaritaville Beach House is on the Key West side and requires a short drive or taxi to Old Town.
The Perry is the clear choice: it has a 288-slip deep-water marina with full services and dockside access.
No — both properties welcome guests of all ages, though standard minimum check-in age policies (21+) typically apply.
Supplier listing mentions a 'Health or beauty spa nearby'; an on-site branded full-service spa is not published.
Explore how The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·