
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Best for boaters, families, and travelers who want a full-service marina and multiple on-site dining options.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a 100-room waterfront hotel on Stock Island with a 288-slip marina and family-friendly facilities; read this if you want marina access, on-site restaurants, and shuttle service to Old Town. Orchid Key Inn is an adults-only, 24-room boutique on Duval Street; read this if you want a compact, highly rated stay steps from bars, galleries, and Key West’s Old Town attractions.
Updated · about 5 miles (8 km) apart

Best for boaters, families, and travelers who want a full-service marina and multiple on-site dining options.

Best for couples and adults who want a very central Duval Street location and a small, highly rated boutique property.
When The Perry wins: Choose The Perry if you want marina access, larger grounds, two waterfront pools, on-site dockside dining, pet-friendly rooms, or event/wedding spaces for bigger groups.
When Orchid Key Inn wins: Choose Orchid Key Inn if you want to stay in Old Town on Duval Street at a small, adults-only inn with top guest ratings and a single-pool, intimate setting.
Bottom line: Pick The Perry for space, marina activities, and family- or group-oriented stays; pick Orchid Key Inn for a compact, highly rated adults-only base steps from Duval Street.
| Category | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West | Orchid Key Inn |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Waterfront marina resort with resort-fee amenities and event spaces | Adults-only boutique inn on Duval Street, small and intimate |
| Location | Stock Island, about 5 miles from Duval Street; complimentary shuttle to Old Town | On Duval Street in Old Town, steps from bars, attractions and museums |
| Size | 100 rooms and suites across three floors | 24 individually furnished guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21 | Adults-only; guests under 18 are not permitted (minimum check-in age 18 at property listing) |
| Pools & hot tubs | Two outdoor waterfront pools (one heated) and poolside bars | One outdoor pool and one hot tub; poolside bar available |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues including Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar and Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill plus poolside bars | One bar/lounge and poolside bar; complimentary continental breakfast |
| Spa & wellness | No branded on-site spa; partner massage services and Saturday lawn yoga available | No branded spa listed; property lists hot tub and limited wellness features |
| Known for | Largest wet-slip marina in the Florida Keys, marina activities, on-site dining and event spaces | Prime Duval Street address and very high guest ratings |
| Accessibility & transport | Complimentary hourly shuttle to Old Town, on-site parking (fees may apply), ADA rooms and accessible paths | Central walkable location in Old Town; self parking available (surcharge); some accessible features |
| Pets | Dog-friendly (fees apply; dogs not allowed on pool deck) | Not published |
The Perry sits on Stock Island beside a large deep-water marina, minutes from downtown Key West but across one bridge.
Good if you want waterfront and easy boating access and don’t mind the short transfer to downtown.
Orchid Key Inn is on Duval Street in Old Town, a short walk from galleries, bars and Key West attractions.
Best if you want to be in the middle of Old Town with minimal transit time to sights and nightlife.
The Perry offers 100 rooms and suites with a range of layouts for families, couples and pet owners.
Choose The Perry for variety, larger rooms and pet-friendly options.
Orchid Key Inn has 24 individually furnished guestrooms focused on adults and couples.
Choose Orchid for a small, boutique selection of rooms aimed at adults and couples.
The Perry has several on-site dining outlets and casual waterfront options for guests.
A wider on-site dining program makes The Perry convenient for meals without driving into Old Town.
Orchid Key Inn has a small food-and-drink footprint and provides a complimentary continental breakfast.
Orchid relies on its prime location on Duval for meal options rather than many on-site restaurants.
The Perry’s standout features are its marina and two outdoor waterfront pools with marina views.
The Perry is for guests who want bigger pool spaces and marina scenery.
Orchid Key Inn offers a smaller pool area and a hot tub suitable for a quieter, adult-only stay.
Orchid’s pool area suits couples or adults who prefer an intimate, central setting.
The Perry provides 24-hour fitness, partner massage services, and sizeable event/wedding spaces.
Pick The Perry for on-site fitness options, wedding/event capacity, and a quieter night adjacent to a marina.
Orchid Key Inn puts you steps from Key West’s nightlife on Duval Street with a limited on-site wellness footprint.
Orchid is better if you want to walk to nightlife and prioritize location over on-site wellness amenities.

The Perry — a 288-slip deep-water marina with direct access to boating, diving and charters.

Orchid Key Inn — a small adults-only property literally on Duval Street, steps from Old Town attractions.

The Perry — family-friendly rooms and a dog-friendly policy with onsite dog exercise areas.

Orchid Key Inn — boutique scale and an adults-only policy make it ideal for couples seeking intimacy.
Orchid Key Inn is on Duval Street; The Perry is on Stock Island about 5 miles from Duval Street (shuttle available).
The Perry is dog-friendly (fees apply, dogs not allowed on the pool deck). Orchid Key Inn’s public listing does not publish a pet policy here.
The Perry — it has a 288-slip deep-water marina and on-property access to sailing, motor boating, and scuba diving operators.
Orchid Key Inn — located on Duval Street within easy walking distance of bars, galleries and Key West’s Old Town attractions.
Explore how The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·