
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Best for travelers who want a working deep-water marina, waterfront rooms on Stock Island, and easy boat access or marina services.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a 100-room waterfront boutique on Stock Island with a 288-slip deep-water marina, two outdoor pools, dockside dining, and family-friendly policies — read this if you want a marina-focused stay outside Old Town with free shuttle access. Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa is a full-service, branded waterfront resort steps from Duval Street and the Key West Bight — read this if you want a centrally located resort with a recognized brand, on-site spa services, and easy walking access to Old Town.
Updated · about 5 miles apart

Best for travelers who want a working deep-water marina, waterfront rooms on Stock Island, and easy boat access or marina services.

Best for visitors who want a central Old Town location, a branded full-service resort experience, and a hotel close to Duval Street attractions.
When The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West wins: choose The Perry if you prioritize marina access, on-site boat services and slips, a quieter location on Stock Island, dog-friendly rooms, and complimentary shuttle service into Old Town.
When Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa wins: choose Hyatt Centric if you want to be within steps of Duval Street and waterfront attractions, prefer a larger branded resort with an on-site spa, and value being in the heart of Key West's downtown harbor area.
Bottom line: The Perry is the practical pick for boaters, pet owners, and guests who want waterfront marina life and a quieter base; Hyatt Centric is the better pick for travelers who want to be in Old Town, close to bars, restaurants, and harborfront sights with a full-service resort setup.
| Category | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West | Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique marina hotel with a relaxed, waterfront focus | Upscale branded waterfront resort in downtown Key West |
| Location (to Old Town/Duval) | On Stock Island, roughly 5 miles / ~20 minutes from Duval Street (complimentary shuttle available) | Steps from Duval Street and Key West Harbor (about 0.2 mi / 0.4 km to Duval) |
| Size | 100 rooms and suites across three floors | 120 rooms (hotel listing) |
| Ages / policy | All-ages property; 21+ to check in | All-ages property; 18+ to check in (property minimum age 18 listed) |
| Pools | Two outdoor waterfront pools (one heated), poolside bars | One outdoor pool, poolside bar and loungers |
| Restaurants & bars | Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar + Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill + two pool bars (dockside dining) | Four Flamingos Key West (restaurant) plus bar/lounge and poolside bar; room service during limited hours |
| Spa & wellness | Partner-arranged massages and occasional lawn yoga; no branded on-site spa | Full-service on-site spa offering massages, body treatments, and facials |
| Known for | Largest deep-water marina in the Florida Keys (288 slips) and marina-focused programming | Central waterfront address, branded Hyatt experience, and walking access to Old Town |
| Shuttle / transport | Complimentary hourly shuttle to Old Town (roughly 9am–11pm) | No hotel shuttle published; very short walk to Old Town attractions |
| Pet policy | Dog-friendly — up to 2 dogs per room; $75/night first dog, $25/night second dog; dogs not allowed on pool deck | Pet policy: Not published |
| Resort fee & parking | Mandatory resort fee (property-stated; covers shuttle, towels, fitness access, etc.); self/valet parking available | Self parking (surcharge) is available; optional fees for breakfast and parking listed |
The Perry sits on Stock Island at a working deep-water marina, a short drive or shuttle ride from Old Town.
Choose The Perry for marina access and a quieter base a few miles from Old Town.
Hyatt Centric sits on the harbor in Old Town, within easy walking distance of Duval Street and waterfront attractions.
Choose Hyatt Centric to be in the middle of Key West's downtown action and harborfront sights.
The Perry offers 100 rooms and suites with waterfront and marina-facing options across a boutique property.
The Perry is a good pick for guests who want rooms with direct marina or waterfront views and family-friendly layouts.
Hyatt Centric provides 120 air-conditioned rooms with private furnished balconies and a range of partial- and full-ocean-view options.
Hyatt Centric suits travelers who prefer a predictable branded room product and easy access to Old Town from a balcony-view room.
Dining at The Perry centers on dockside seafood and casual waterfront fare.
Pick The Perry for dockside seafood and casual waterfront meals with marina views.
Hyatt Centric's dining includes Four Flamingos Key West with ocean views, plus a bar and poolside service.
Choose Hyatt Centric if you want downtown dining with ocean views and the convenience of an on-site branded restaurant.
The Perry's signature amenity is its marina and related boating services, backed by two outdoor waterfront pools.
The Perry is stronger for guests who want to be near boats and enjoy multiple waterfront pools with marina views.
Hyatt Centric has a single outdoor pool with poolside seating and direct harborfront sightlines near Old Town.
Hyatt Centric fits travelers who want a downtown pool as part of a full-service resort experience.
The Perry offers fitness and occasional wellness classes, with easy access to nightlife via shuttle or a short drive into Old Town.
The Perry supports basic wellness on site and requires a short trip to reach most Old Town nightlife.
Hyatt Centric provides a full-service spa, 24-hour fitness, and immediate walking access to Key West nightlife.
Hyatt Centric is the better pick for guests who want on-site spa services and to walk straight into Key West nightlife.

The Perry — a 288-slip deep-water marina with fuel, shore power, and service for large vessels makes it the obvious choice for boaters.

Hyatt Centric — steps from Duval Street, Mallory Square, and harbor attractions, ideal for walkable Old Town sightseeing and nightlife.

The Perry — dog-friendly rooms, two dog exercise areas, and clear pet fees/policies tailored for traveling dogs.

Hyatt Centric — a recognizable Hyatt property with an on-site spa, concierge services, and a downtown waterfront address.
Hyatt Centric is steps from Duval Street and downtown attractions; The Perry is on Stock Island about 5 miles away with a complimentary shuttle into Old Town.
The Perry is explicitly dog-friendly with on-site dog exercise areas and published pet fees; Hyatt Centric's pet policy is not published in the supplied listing.
Hyatt Centric lists a full-service on-site spa with massage and body treatments; The Perry offers partner-arranged massages and occasional yoga but does not operate a branded on-site spa.
The Perry — it operates a 288-slip deep-water marina with services for boats and easy access to sailing, diving, and motor boating from the property.
Explore how The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·