
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Best for marina-focused stays, dockside dining, and a compact boutique property with easy shuttle access to Old Town.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a 100-room boutique marina hotel on Stock Island with a 288-slip deep-water marina, two waterfront pools and dockside restaurants — a practical pick for guests who want marina life and an hourly shuttle to Old Town. Hilton Key West Resort & Marina is a larger, branded 4-star marina resort near Old Town with multiple pools, marina access, and full Hilton services — best for travelers who prefer a familiar brand, more pool options, and a larger resort footprint.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for marina-focused stays, dockside dining, and a compact boutique property with easy shuttle access to Old Town.

Best for guests who want a larger branded resort with more pools, on-site water-sport options, and conventional Hilton services.
When The Perry wins: Choose The Perry if you want a boutique marina experience (288-slip deep-water marina), dockside restaurants like Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar, two waterfront pools, direct marina access for diving and private charters, and a smaller property that feels more intimate.
When Hilton wins: Choose Hilton Key West Resort & Marina if you prefer a larger resort with more pool options (supplier listing shows 6 outdoor pools), on-site boat tours and a broad set of rental options and recreational activities under a well-known brand and multilingual concierge services.
Bottom line: Both hotels offer marina access and water-based activities; pick The Perry for boutique, marina-first stays and dockside dining close to Stock Island operations, and pick Hilton for a bigger, branded resort experience with more pools and conventional resort amenities.
| Category | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West | Hilton Key West Resort & Marina |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique waterfront marina hotel, compact and focused on marina life and dockside dining | Branded waterfront resort with a larger, full-service resort layout and multiple pools |
| Location | Stock Island (7001 Shrimp Road), minutes from Old Town via complimentary shuttle | Peninsular Avenue (5950 Peninsular Avenue), Old Town waterfront area / Stock Island vicinity |
| Size (rooms) | 100 rooms and suites | 175 guestrooms |
| Ages / check-in | Family-friendly; minimum check-in age 21 | |
| Pools | Two outdoor waterfront pools (one heated), two poolside bars | Six outdoor pools, poolside bar(s) |
| Restaurants & bars | Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar, Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill, two pool bars (plus occasional partners) | One restaurant, one coffee shop/cafe, bar and poolside bar(s) (supplier listing) |
| Spa & wellness | Partner massage services and on-site yoga classes; no branded in-house spa | Not published |
| Marina & water activities | 288-slip deep-water marina (largest in the Keys), on-site scuba, sailing, motor boating, boat/dolphin tours nearby | Marina on site with boat tours, motorized watercraft and water activities available |
| Key practicals | Free WiFi, 24-hour fitness, mandatory resort fee, complimentary hourly shuttle to Old Town | Free WiFi, 24-hour fitness, wired internet (surcharge available), self-parking (surcharge) |
| Pet policy | Dog-friendly (fee: $75/night first dog, $25/night second dog; dogs not allowed on pool deck) | Food and water bowls listed; supplier notes a pet fee will be charged but details vary |
The Perry sits on Stock Island’s marina complex, roughly five miles from Duval Street and the Old Town waterfront; a complimentary hourly shuttle runs to downtown.
The Perry is ideal if you want to be right at a working marina and don’t mind the short shuttle or drive into Old Town.
Hilton Key West Resort & Marina sits near the Old Town waterfront area / Stock Island vicinity with marina access and easy routes into downtown Key West.
The Hilton keeps you close to Old Town attractions while still offering marina services and on-site water activities.
The Perry has 100 rooms and suites across a small property with a mix of rooms and studio suites, many with water or pool views.
Choose The Perry for smaller-scale, marina-facing rooms and a boutique layout.
Hilton offers a broad selection of room types (supplier lists many partial-ocean and ocean-view rooms and suites).
Hilton suits travelers who want more room type choices, larger suite options and predictable brand-standard amenities.
The Perry’s on-site dining centers on waterfront, seafood-driven options and casual dockside grills.
The Perry emphasizes dockside seafood and multiple casual waterfront outlets within the property.
Hilton lists one main restaurant, a coffee shop/cafe and bar options in its supplier listing — standard resort dining with on-site room service during limited hours.
Hilton gives a conventional resort dining setup with one primary restaurant and poolside bar service.
The Perry centers much guest life around its two outdoor waterfront pools and marina setting.
If you want fewer, marina-facing pools and immediate dockside access, The Perry is focused on that layout.
Hilton lists multiple pools and expanded poolside facilities in its supplier listing.
Hilton is better if you want more and varied pool spaces across a larger property.
The Perry provides 24-hour fitness, partner massage services, Saturday lawn yoga and local evening dining/live music at dockside spots.
The Perry mixes basic fitness with partner wellness services and local evening dining/music.
Hilton lists a 24-hour fitness center and various on-site activity rentals and tours; supplier listing does not publish an on-site branded spa.
Hilton offers conventional fitness plus on-site activity booking; a branded spa is not published in the supplier listing.

The Perry — the property sits on a 288-slip deep-water marina and supports diving, private charters and direct boat access.

Hilton Key West Resort & Marina — supplier listing shows six outdoor pools and multiple poolside facilities.

The Perry — Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar and Salty Oyster provide multiple dockside dining options on property.

Hilton Key West Resort & Marina — Hilton-brand standards, multilingual staff and larger-room inventory suit travelers wanting brand consistency.
The Perry — it’s built around a 288-slip deep-water marina and lists on-site scuba, motor boating and easy access to dive operators.
Both are located on the Old Town/Stock Island fringe, but The Perry uses a complimentary hourly shuttle to Old Town; drive times vary by traffic. Either property requires a short drive or shuttle into central Duval Street.
No. Both properties welcome guests of all ages; both list a minimum check-in age of 21 for the registering guest.
Not published — the supplier listing does not clearly list a branded in-house spa.
The Perry is explicitly dog-friendly with a published fee structure and dog exercise areas. Hilton’s supplier listing notes food/water bowls and a pet fee may apply, but specific Hilton pet terms are not fully published in the supplied listing.
Explore how The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·