
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Best for boaters and people who want direct marina access, dockside restaurants, and a quieter Stock Island setting.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a 100-room waterfront boutique hotel on Stock Island with a 288-slip deep-water marina and two marina-view pools—good for travelers who want marina access, dockside dining, and a quieter base near Old Town. DoubleTree Resort by Hilton Grand Key - Key West is a larger branded resort near Smathers Beach and the airport—read this if you prefer a familiar Hilton property with conference space, a beach shuttle, and conventional resort services.
Updated

Best for boaters and people who want direct marina access, dockside restaurants, and a quieter Stock Island setting.

Best for travelers who want a larger resort near the beach with more meeting space, a branded loyalty option, and a free airport shuttle.
When The Perry wins: choose The Perry if you value an on-site deep-water marina, waterfront dining, poolside bars with marina views, and a smaller boutique property that still runs a frequent shuttle to Old Town.
When DoubleTree wins: pick DoubleTree if you want a familiar Hilton-branded resort with more guestrooms, a single outdoor pool, a conference center (about 7,000 sq ft), and complementary airport transport and beach shuttles.
Bottom line: The Perry is the better choice for marina-focused stays, dockside dining, and a boutique feel; DoubleTree is the sensible pick for convention or family groups who want a larger branded resort near Smathers Beach and the airport.
| Category | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West | DoubleTree Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique, marina-focused, quieter Stock Island setting | Large branded resort-style hotel near the airport and beaches |
| Location (to Old Town/Duval) | About 5 miles / roughly 20 minutes to Duval Street (Stock Island) | About 3.8 miles / 4–6 minute drive to Duval Street (near Smathers Beach) |
| Size / rooms | 100 rooms and suites (boutique, 3 floors) | 216 guestrooms |
| Pools | Two outdoor waterfront pools (one heated) with two poolside bars | One outdoor pool with poolside bar(s) |
| Restaurants & bars | Two dockside restaurants (Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar; Salty Oyster) + two poolside bars | One on-site restaurant (Palm Haven) + a bar and poolside bar; buffet breakfast available (fee) |
| Spa & wellness | Partner-arranged in-room or poolside massages, 24-hour fitness center, lawn yoga (Sat) | Not published |
| Marina / beach access | 288-slip deep-water marina on property (largest in the Keys); marina services and boat access | Near Smathers Beach; complimentary beach shuttle |
| Business & events | Multiple event venues and meeting rooms (over 20,000 sq ft across event spaces; Latitude/Longitude rooms listed) | Conference center and meeting rooms totaling about 7,000 sq ft (conference/balroom) |
| Airport transfer | Complimentary hourly shuttle to Old Town; Key West International ~3 miles away | Complimentary roundtrip airport shuttle (on request); Key West Intl ~1.1 mi away |
| Pets | Dog-friendly (dogs allowed in rooms; on-site dog exercise areas; pet fees apply) | Pets allowed in specific rooms only (pet fee listed) |
The Perry sits on Stock Island’s working marina, a short drive or shuttle ride from Old Town.
Best if you want a quieter waterfront location with marina access and a regular shuttle into downtown Key West.
DoubleTree sits on S. Roosevelt Blvd near Smathers Beach and a short drive from the airport and downtown.
Better if you prefer a hotel close to Key West’s main beach and the airport rather than a marina setting.
The Perry is a smaller property with 100 rooms and suites across three floors.
Choose The Perry for a smaller-room inventory and specific suite options; ideal for travelers who want a boutique feel and marina views.
DoubleTree offers 216 guestrooms with standard resort-style amenities.
Pick DoubleTree if you want a larger selection of standard resort rooms and the predictability of a branded property.
The Perry’s dining centers on waterfront and dockside experiences.
The Perry emphasizes waterfront, seafood-forward dining and casual dockside options.
DoubleTree has one primary on-site restaurant plus bar and poolside service.
DoubleTree is a straightforward resort dining option with one main restaurant and poolside service, suitable for guests who want simple, on-site meals.
The Perry provides two outdoor waterfront pools overlooking the marina.
The Perry focuses on marina-view pool time rather than direct beach access.
DoubleTree has an outdoor resort pool and a complimentary beach shuttle to Smathers Beach.
DoubleTree is convenient if you want to split time between a hotel pool and nearby Smathers Beach via shuttle.
The Perry offers partner massage services, a 24-hour fitness center, and occasional lawn yoga.
The Perry supports wellness through on-demand services and fitness rather than a full spa roster.
DoubleTree lists a 24-hour fitness center and a range of nearby watersports and activities.
DoubleTree provides standard resort fitness offerings and arranges beach or water activities; a dedicated spa is not published.

The Perry — an on-site 288-slip deep-water marina and direct boat services make it the clear choice for guests arriving by sea or planning boating excursions.

DoubleTree — larger room count, meeting space, and a complimentary airport shuttle suit travelers who prefer the consistency of a Hilton brand.

The Perry — multiple dockside restaurants and pool bars provide more waterfront dining variety without leaving the property.

DoubleTree — located near Smathers Beach with a free beach shuttle for easy sand-and-swim days.
Pick The Perry — it has a 288-slip deep-water marina on site and direct marina services for boating, sailing, and scuba departures.
DoubleTree is closer to Key West International Airport (the supplier listing notes the airport is about 1.1 mi away); The Perry is roughly 3 miles from the airport.
Yes. The Perry operates a complimentary hourly shuttle to Old Town, and DoubleTree offers a complimentary roundtrip airport shuttle and a free beach shuttle; DoubleTree’s listing does not promise an Old Town shuttle.
Yes. Both properties allow children; neither is adults-only, though The Perry requires a registering guest to be at least 21 to check in.
Explore how The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·