
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Best for boaters, marina access and dockside dining right on property.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a waterfront, family-friendly hotel on Stock Island with a large deep-water marina, two outdoor waterfront pools and dockside dining; read this if you want easy boat access or a marina-side stay minutes from Old Town. The Gates Hotel Key West is a modern, 4-star lifestyle hotel near the airport and New Town attractions; read this if you prefer a contemporary property a short drive from downtown and the botanical garden.
Updated · about 3.5 km apart

Best for boaters, marina access and dockside dining right on property.

Best for travelers who want a contemporary, conveniently located hotel near Key West Intl. and New Town sights.
When The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West wins: choose The Perry if your priority is marina access, waterfront pools and on-site dockside restaurants — it’s the clear pick for guests arriving by boat or who want the marina lifestyle and hourly shuttle to Old Town.
When The Gates Hotel Key West wins: choose The Gates if you want a modern, accessible hotel closer to Key West Intl. and New Town attractions, with straightforward facilities, free Wi‑Fi and a single outdoor pool in a refreshed contemporary property.
Bottom line: Both hotels make practical bases for exploring Key West; pick The Perry for marina-focused stays, waterfront dining and larger pool space, or pick The Gates for a newer, modern hotel near the airport and New Town points of interest.
| Category | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West | The Gates Hotel Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Marina-centered, waterfront resort with casual-elegant dockside dining. | Contemporary lifestyle hotel at the entrance to Key West (New Town). |
| Location | Stock Island waterfront, about 5 miles / a shuttle ride from Old Town. | New Town (N Roosevelt Blvd), a short drive from Key West Intl. Airport and nearby botanical garden. |
| Size | 100 rooms and suites across three floors. | |
| Who can stay / check-in age | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age is 21. | |
| Pools | Two outdoor waterfront pools (one heated), poolside bars and lounge seating. | One outdoor pool and a poolside bar; pool access and umbrellas available. |
| Restaurants & bars | Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar (waterfront) + Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill and poolside bars; dockside dining available. | Two restaurants and a coffee shop/cafe on site, plus a poolside bar/lounge. |
| Spa & wellness | No dedicated branded spa; partner massage services, lawn yoga and a 24-hour fitness center. | Fitness facilities on site; health/beauty spa nearby (per supplier listing). |
| Known for | 288-slip deep-water marina, boat access, marina events and dockside dining. | Modern design, accessibility features and convenient access to New Town attractions. |
| Accessibility & family features | ADA-compliant rooms and accessible paths; family-friendly with shuttle to Old Town. | Multiple wheelchair-accessible features and accessible public washrooms; family stays allowed. |
| Parking & transport | On-site self and valet parking; complimentary hourly shuttle to Old Town. | On-site uncovered self parking (surcharge) and area shuttle (surcharge); close to Key West Intl. |
The Perry sits on Stock Island’s large deep-water marina a short drive or shuttle ride from Old Town Key West.
Choose The Perry for a marina-side base and easy on-water access while still reaching Old Town by shuttle.
The Gates sits in New Town near N Roosevelt Blvd and Key West Intl., convenient for airport arrivals and nearby attractions.
Choose The Gates if you want a modern hotel near the airport and New Town attractions rather than Old Town’s center.
The Perry offers 100 rooms and suites including waterfront studios and multi-room suites with marina views.
Pick The Perry for variety in room types, suites and the option to stay next to the marina.
The Gates provides modern, accessible rooms in a 4-star lifestyle setting.
Pick The Gates if you prefer newer, accessible rooms and straightforward amenities near New Town.
Dining at The Perry centers on waterfront restaurants and casual dockside options.
The Perry is the choice for more extensive dockside dining and waterfront meals.
The Gates offers two on-site restaurants and a coffee shop/cafe for straightforward meals.
The Gates suits guests who want modern, convenient on-site dining without the marina/dockside focus.
The Perry has two outdoor waterfront pools, one of which is heated and both with sun loungers and poolside bars.
If pool time with marina views matters, The Perry offers more pool space and atmosphere.
The Gates features one outdoor pool and an outdoor entertainment area.
The Gates provides a compact pool setup suitable for guests who prioritize a modern hotel over multiple pool options.
The Perry combines a 24-hour fitness center with partner-provided massage services and occasional yoga classes.
The Perry is for travelers wanting fitness access and ad-hoc wellness services alongside lively evening dining options.
The Gates has fitness facilities and lists evening entertainment among its on-site amenities.
Choose The Gates if you want basic fitness options and easy access to local tours and entertainment near New Town.

The Perry — 288-slip deep-water marina and on-site dock services make it far more convenient for guests arriving by boat or arranging charters.

The Gates — a contemporary hotel close to Key West Intl. with many accessibility features and straightforward road access.

The Perry — multiple dockside dining options including Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar and casual dockside grills.

The Gates — modern rooms, a clear set of accessible amenities and on-site dining in New Town.
The Gates is closer to Key West International Airport; The Perry is on Stock Island a short drive from the airport.
The Perry is the clear choice — it has a 288-slip deep-water marina and direct dock access for boating and charters.
No — both properties welcome guests of all ages, though both list a minimum check-in age of 21.
The Perry — it offers two outdoor waterfront pools (one heated) compared with The Gates’ single outdoor pool.
Explore how The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·