
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Best for families, boaters, and guests who want a full-service marina and more on-site dining and event space.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a 100-room waterfront hotel on Stock Island with a large deep-water marina and family-friendly amenities — choose it if you want marina access, poolside dining, and easy boat charters. H2O Suites is a 22-room, adults-only boutique all-suite hotel steps from Duval Street — pick it if you want a small, quiet, adult-focused base in Old Town.
Updated · about 5 miles (≈8 km) apart

Best for families, boaters, and guests who want a full-service marina and more on-site dining and event space.

Best for couples and adults who want a very small, central Old Town hotel with suite layouts and private plunge-pool options.
When The Perry wins: choose The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West if you want a marina on property, multiple waterfront dining options, larger grounds and event facilities, family- and pet-friendly rules, and shuttle access to Old Town.
When H2O Suites wins: choose H2O Suites when you want a small adults-only property within walking distance of Duval Street, compact luxury suites (several with personal plunge pools), and a quiet Old Town location.
Bottom line: for marina access, more restaurants and bigger public spaces pick The Perry; for an intimate, adults-only Old Town stay in a suite pick H2O Suites.
| Category | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West | H2O Suites |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Waterfront resort with marina, family-friendly and activity-focused | Small, adults-only boutique all-suite hotel in Old Town |
| Location (closest neighborhood) | Stock Island — waterfront, minutes from downtown by shuttle or car | Old Town Key West — steps from Duval Street and nearby beaches |
| Size | 100 rooms and suites across three floors | 22 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Minimum check-in age / policy | Primary guest must be at least 21; property is all-ages (children welcome) | Min age 25 to check in; adults-only property — guests under 25 not permitted |
| Pools | Two outdoor waterfront pools (one heated), two poolside bars | One outdoor pool and a poolside bar |
| Restaurants & bars | Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar, Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill, two poolside bars (plus variable other outlets) | Bar/lounge and poolside bar noted; full-service restaurant not published |
| Spa / wellness | No branded on-site spa; partner massage services and Saturday lawn yoga; 24-hour fitness center | Not published |
| Known for / standout feature | 288-slip deep-water marina and dockside restaurants/event venues | Steps from Duval Street, several suites with private plunge pools, adults-only policy |
| Parking & transport | Self and valet parking on-site; complimentary hourly shuttle to Old Town | Self parking (surcharge) listed; very walkable to Old Town attractions |
| Wi‑Fi & connectivity | Free Wi‑Fi in rooms and public areas | |
The Perry sits on Stock Island’s marina waterfront, a short drive or the hotel’s shuttle ride from Old Town Key West.
Choose The Perry if you want marina access and don’t mind being on Stock Island rather than in Old Town.
H2O Suites is in Old Town Key West, within steps of Duval Street and close to South Beach and tourist sites.
Choose H2O Suites for maximum walkability to Old Town attractions and nightlife.
The Perry has 100 rooms and suites across several room types, including multiple suite sizes for families and couples.
The Perry is better if you need variety of room sizes and family-friendly configurations.
H2O Suites is an all-suite property with individually decorated guestrooms, several offering private plunge pools or balconies.
H2O Suites is for travelers who want suite-style rooms and private plunge-pool options in a very small property.
The Perry has multiple on-site restaurants and pool/dockside bars for full meals and casual bites.
Pick The Perry if you want more on-site full-service dining and dockside choices.
H2O Suites lists a bar/lounge and poolside bar but no full-service restaurant in the supplier listing.
H2O Suites works if you plan to dine out in Old Town rather than rely on hotel restaurants.
The Perry’s marina and multiple waterfront pools define its public spaces.
The Perry is the clear choice for boaters and guests who want waterfront pool variety plus marina services.
H2O Suites centers on small property comfort with one outdoor pool and several suites that include private plunge pools.
H2O Suites is best if a private plunge pool or a quieter single-pool setting near Old Town matters most.
The Perry offers a 24-hour fitness center, partner massage services and hotel-driven weekend wellness programming.
For fitness options and organized wellness services plus on-site evening dining, pick The Perry.
H2O Suites provides fitness facilities and immediate access to Old Town nightlife, with quieter on-site spaces.
If you want to stay within easy walking distance of Old Town nightlife but keep quieter, adult-only accommodations, H2O fits.

The Perry — 288-slip deep-water marina and dockside services on property.

H2O Suites — steps from Duval Street and close to South Beach and Old Town attractions.

The Perry — family-friendly, dog-friendly rooms and on-site dog exercise areas.

H2O Suites — small adults-only property with several suites that include private plunge pools.
H2O Suites is in Old Town — steps from Duval Street. The Perry is on Stock Island and is roughly a 15–25 minute drive or a shuttle ride from Old Town.
The Perry welcomes children and dogs (dog fee applies) and has family-friendly rooms and two on-site dog exercise areas; H2O Suites is adults-only and does not permit guests under its minimum age policy.
Yes — H2O Suites lists multiple room types with a personal plunge pool. The Perry’s rooms do not list private plunge pools.
The Perry has multiple on-site restaurants and pool/dockside bars (Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar, Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill, two poolside bars). H2O Suites lists a bar/lounge and poolside bar but no full-service restaurant in its supplier listing.
Explore how The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·