
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Best for boaters and guests who want direct marina access and dockside dining near a working harbor.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a waterfront, 100-room boutique hotel on Stock Island with a large deep-water marina and two outdoor pools; it suits travelers who want marina access, pool time, and easy Old Town shuttle service. Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses is a large Southernmost Point–area beach resort and guesthouse collection on Duval Street for travelers who want a recognizable beachfront address close to downtown Key West attractions.
Updated · about 5 miles apart

Best for boaters and guests who want direct marina access and dockside dining near a working harbor.

Best for travelers prioritizing a beachfront location and immediate access to Old Town attractions.
When The Perry wins: choose The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West if you want marina facilities (288 deep-water slips), two waterfront pools, dockside restaurants, on-site boat activity and a quieter Stock Island base with a free hourly shuttle into Old Town.
When Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses wins: pick Southernmost if you prefer a central Duval Street/Southernmost Point address, beach access steps from the property, and a larger resort/guesthouse footprint closer to downtown Key West sights and bars.
Bottom line: The Perry is the practical choice for marina users, boaters, and guests wanting a waterside, slightly removed stay with shuttle service; Southernmost is the simpler pick for visitors who want to be on or beside the beach and within walking distance of Old Town landmarks.
| Category | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West | Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Marina-focused, relaxed waterfront boutique | Large beachside resort and guesthouse collection near Southernmost Point |
| Location | Stock Island — waterfront marina, minutes from downtown by shuttle or car | Duval Street / Southernmost Point area — beachfront and central to Old Town attractions |
| Size | 100 rooms and suites | Not published |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; 21+ to check in | All ages welcome; 18+ to check in (check-in min age: 18 years) |
| Pools / beach | Two outdoor waterfront pools (one heated) and poolside bars; no beach on site | On-site beach access plus outdoor pool(s) and poolside bar(s) |
| Restaurants & bars | Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar, Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill, two poolside bars; dockside dining | Multiple on-site restaurants and bars (beachside); specific signature restaurant names Not published |
| Spa & wellness | 24-hour fitness center; partner massage services and Saturday lawn yoga (no branded on-site spa) | Spa and massage services listed; details and branded spa name Not published |
| Known for | Largest deep-water marina in the Florida Keys (288 slips) and wedding/event spaces | Familiar Southernmost branding and immediate beachside location near the Southernmost Point |
| Transport & access | Complimentary hourly shuttle to Old Town (running ~9am–11pm), on-site parking and marina access | Central Old Town/Duval location — walkable to downtown attractions; on-site car parking (charges may apply) |
| Pet policy | Dog-friendly (fee, two dogs max; dogs not allowed on pool deck) | Not published |
The Perry sits on Stock Island at the Stock Island Marina, a working deep-water harbor about five miles from Old Town Key West.
Better if you want a waterfront marina base and don't mind a short shuttle or drive to Old Town.
Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses is located on Duval Street near the Southernmost Point — beachfront and within walking distance of many Old Town attractions.
Better if you want to be centrally located on the Old Town side of Key West with immediate beach and Duval Street access.
The Perry offers 100 rooms and suites across a small, three-floor boutique property with several studio and suite layouts.
Good if you want compact, waterfront-oriented rooms and a clear set of studio/suite types plus pet options.
Southernmost lists a broad range of room types across its resort and guesthouse footprint to fit couples and families.
Better if you want many room category choices, beachfront views or specific configurations (balcony/ocean view).
Dining at The Perry centers on dockside seafood and casual waterfront options.
Choose The Perry for consistent dockside dining and two poolside bars beside the marina.
Southernmost offers multiple on-site restaurants and bars oriented to beachside dining and convenience to Duval Street.
Pick Southernmost if you prefer beach-adjacent dining and direct access to Duval Street food and nightlife.
The Perry features two outdoor waterfront pools (one heated) with poolside bars and marina views.
Best for guests who want pool decks with marina views rather than a sandy beach.
Southernmost provides direct beach access plus outdoor pools and poolside bars as part of its beachfront offering.
Choose Southernmost for immediate sand-and-sea access and a classic Old Town beachside experience.
The Perry offers a 24-hour fitness center, partner massage services, and lawn yoga sessions at times.
Good for guests who want fitness and on-demand massage plus an easy shuttle into Key West's evening scene.
Southernmost lists spa and massage among its amenities and sits steps from Duval Street nightlife.
Better if you want beachfront spa access and immediate walking distance to Duval Street nightlife.

The Perry — a 288-slip deep-water marina and direct dockside access make it the clear choice for boat owners and anglers.

Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses — immediate beach access and a Duval/Southernmost Point address put you steps from the sand.

Southernmost — located on Duval Street, it's the easier option for walking to museums, restaurants and nightlife.

The Perry — Stock Island location gives a more relaxed waterfront setting while still providing shuttle access to downtown.
Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses is on Duval Street and within walking distance of Old Town attractions; The Perry is on Stock Island about five miles away with a complimentary shuttle.
Choose The Perry — it operates a 288-slip deep-water marina with services and direct marina access.
No. Neither property is all-inclusive; meals are charged separately unless a specific package states otherwise.
Yes. Both properties accept guests of all ages, though The Perry requires the primary registering guest to be at least 21 to check in and Southernmost’s supplier listing shows a minimum check-in age of 18.
Explore how The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·