
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Best for travelers who want a marina, waterfront pools, on-site dockside restaurants and an hourly shuttle to Old Town.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a waterfront, family-friendly boutique hotel on Stock Island with marina access and multiple dockside restaurants; read this if you want active waterfront facilities, a marina, and easy Old Town shuttle service. The Gardens Hotel is an elegant 4-star boutique garden hotel in Old Town Key West; read this if you want a small, highly rated Old Town base within easy walking distance of Duval Street and Hemingway’s house.
Updated · about 5 miles apart

Best for travelers who want a marina, waterfront pools, on-site dockside restaurants and an hourly shuttle to Old Town.

Best for travelers who want a small, elegant Old Town base within easy walking distance of Duval Street and the Hemingway Home.
When The Perry wins: Choose The Perry if you want waterfront pools with marina views, on-site boating and diving access, multiple casual dining choices on the dock, and a complimentary shuttle to Old Town. It’s the better fit for boaters, families, and guests who value marina services.
When The Gardens wins: Choose The Gardens Hotel if you want to stay inside Old Town within steps of Duval Street and major attractions, prefer a quieter, garden-focused boutique property, and value a top guest rating and complimentary cooked-to-order breakfast.
Bottom line: Pick The Perry for activity-focused waterfront stays and marina access on Stock Island; pick The Gardens for a compact, highly rated Old Town boutique experience close to Key West’s main sights.
| Category | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West | The Gardens Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Marina-centered, casual elegant waterfront resort with active dining and event space | Quiet, elegant Old Town boutique tucked around gardens and pool |
| Location | Stock Island (waterfront), complementary shuttle ~9am–11pm to Old Town | Old Town Key West, steps from Duval Street and Hemingway Home |
| Size | 100 rooms and suites | 21 rooms |
| Who can check in | Primary registering guest must be at least 21 | Property notes a minimum check-in age (policies vary); supplier listing shows some minimums — check booking info |
| Pools | Two outdoor waterfront pools (one heated) with poolside bars | Two outdoor pools; garden setting and pool sun loungers |
| Restaurants & bars | Two dockside restaurants (Matt's Stock Island Kitchen & Bar, Salty Oyster) plus poolside bars | One restaurant and two bars/lounges; complimentary cooked-to-order breakfast |
| Spa & wellness | On-site 24-hour fitness center; partner massage services and Saturday lawn yoga (no branded in-house spa) | Health/beauty spa nearby; yoga classes/instruction on site listed among amenities |
| Known for | 288-slip deep-water marina and marina-side dining | Highly rated Old Town boutique hotel with garden grounds |
| Pets | Dog-friendly (fees apply; dogs not allowed on pool deck) | Pets allowed in specific rooms (pet fees and restrictions apply); policies listed with property |
| Parking & access | On-site self and valet parking; parking fees may apply; complimentary shuttle to Old Town | Self parking (surcharge) and secured parking listed; front desk with limited hours |
The Perry sits on Stock Island’s marina waterfront, several miles from downtown Key West with an hourly shuttle to Old Town.
Choose The Perry for waterfront and marina convenience; expect a short shuttle or drive into Old Town.
The Gardens Hotel is inside Old Town, an easy walk to Duval Street and museums.
Choose The Gardens if you want to walk to restaurants, galleries and the main Old Town sights.
The Perry has 100 rooms across suites and multiple studio/room types with marina or pool views.
Pick The Perry for larger inventory, family-friendly layouts and modern waterfront rooms.
The Gardens Hotel offers 21 air-conditioned rooms and cottages with a garden focus.
Choose The Gardens for a smaller, more intimate room selection and cottage-style lodging in Old Town.
The Perry focuses on casual-elegant waterfront dining with multiple on-site outlets.
The Perry suits guests who want several casual waterfront dining options without leaving property.
The Gardens has one main restaurant listed and a quiet lounge/bar presence.
The Gardens works well if you plan to eat in Old Town and want a quieter hotel dining footprint with a reliable breakfast included.
The Perry’s signature amenity is its deep-water marina and waterfront pool decks.
If marina access and active waterfront pool life matter, The Perry is the clear choice.
The Gardens highlights a garden setting with two outdoor pools for a quieter swim experience.
The Gardens is better for a calm pool-and-garden stay inside Old Town rather than waterfront marina activity.
The Perry offers fitness, partner massage services and on-property evening dining with live music at some outlets.
The Perry provides fitness and arranged wellness services with nightlife at on-site bars and nearby Old Town via shuttle.
The Gardens provides a quieter, garden-based wellness ambience and lists nearby spa options.
Choose The Gardens if you want walkable nightlife and a low-key garden wellness feel; use nearby spas for treatments.

The Perry — 288-slip deep-water marina and on-property boat access make it the logical pick for boaters and diving guests.

The Gardens Hotel — small size, garden grounds and a location steps from Duval Street suit travelers who want Old Town on foot.

The Perry — multiple dockside restaurants and pool bars provide more on-property dining choices.

The Gardens Hotel — a 9.8 guest rating and boutique cottage-style rooms make it a top-rated Old Town option.
The Gardens Hotel is in Old Town within walking distance of Duval Street; The Perry is on Stock Island about a 15–20 minute drive or a shuttle ride away.
The Perry has extensive marina facilities (288 slips) and direct access for boating, sailing and scuba bookings; The Gardens does not advertise marina services.
The Perry is not adults-only and welcomes families (check-in requires a primary guest age 21+). The Gardens Hotel’s supplier listing includes an adults-only policy (restrictions on under-16 guests); check the booking details for confirmation.
The Gardens Hotel generally offers a quieter, garden-centered boutique experience in Old Town. The Perry is livelier with dockside dining, pools and marina activity.
Explore how The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·